Lose the Confederate Flag, Keep the Statues

By Karen

I moved to Richmond, Virginia, from the North 43 years ago this month, and it only recently hit me that I’ve been here nearly one-third of the time the Civil War has been over, and I’ve been reminded of it nearly every blessed day and resented it every time.

After the Charleston shootings, words can’t describe how thrilled I was to see some Southern states begin rethinking the preservation of their blockheaded “heritage” and getting with the 21st century.

In Alabama, without asking anybody’s permission, the Republican governor ordered four Confederate flags removed from the statehouse grounds. Amazing!

In VIRGINIA, our Democratic governor, Terry McAuliffe, ordered Confederate flag license plate issued only to the Sons of Confederate Veterans discontinued and all such plates in use (1,600) replaced. Hallelujah!

The plates were a small gesture, yet the SCV have vowed to fight it — even after the exact case in Texas recently went to the Supreme Court and LOST. (That old, “The South shall rise again!” mentality.)

OK, the flag once stood for the Glorious Cause, but the SCV refuse to acknowledge it’s been hijacked by racists, and racism is what it stands squarely for today.

Some Southerners are wringing their hands over the flag, saying it’s a slippery slope, and what comes down next?

Richmond has a big statue of Jefferson Davis, president of the Confederacy, on Monument Avenue (more on that in a sec) that just got defaced twice. One guy spray-painted an “L” on it to signify “Loser” (which was pretty “Lame”). Someone else painted “Black Lives Matter.”

Monument Avenue is a beautiful tree-lined boulevard with a wide green median, lined with lavish, historic homes and dotted with impressive statues of prominent Civil War figures like Robert E. Lee and Stonewall Jackson on horseback.

It also has one odd, puny statue of black Richmond native and tennis great, Arthur Ashe, who’s posed as if lobbing a book to a bunch of sawed-off kids. Trust me, getting him on Monument Avenue caused everyone no end of angst.

Anyway, people are worried these statues will get torn down à la Saddam Hussein in Baghdad.

If that happens, are statues of slave owners George Washington and Thomas Jefferson safe?

I’d say the distinction is that the statues haven’t been embraced as racist symbols. They’re of people who played key roles in significant events in our past.

Let’s leave the statues of major historical figures alone. They don’t bother anybody, and in most cases they’re works of art that attract tourists and may be a comfort to some.

But statues and busts of relatively minor figures, like Nathan Bedford Forrest who helped start the KKK, belong in museums as curiosities.

Even though all the funerals in Charleston are over, I hope the South keeps progressing toward accepting that the United States is one country again, founded on the principle that all men are created equal — in spite our many, many lapses and some people’s lingering refusal to face it.

Advertisements

3 Responses to Lose the Confederate Flag, Keep the Statues

  1. Keri Wormald says:

    I just had an interesting conversation about the Arthur Ashe statue just yesterday. The Ashe family was quite specific about what they wanted that statue to look like and where they wanted it to live–though your description made me laugh! The statue’s creator, Paul DiPasquali, is a very talented artist (and the husband of my friend actress/singer Kelly Kennedy) and he may have had other ideas too, but he respected Mrs. Ashe’s wishes. Monument Avenue would benefit, tourist-wise, from having MORE statues of prominent Virginians of all ethnicities lining the boulevards. The statues moving westward do need to be smaller than the first erected because the huge intersections are all used up by dead Confederate white guys. NOTE: Confederate leaders who died in battle face NORTH on their bronze horses. Those who survived to Appomattox face SOUTH. I always thought that was a nice touch. It signaled some vague awareness that the South lost the war.

  2. catsworking says:

    Keri, I always knew there was some significance to the way the horses are facing, but I can never remember what it is. Even if I did, I’d need a compass to get it.

    As for the Ashe statue, if that’s how the family wanted it to look, let’s be glad they didn’t design the other monuments or the generals would all be riding legless horses.

    I’ve been reading up a bit on Richmond at the end of Civil War, thanks to the RTD’s OCD. It’s something I’ve managed to totally ignore all these years. I must say I’m shocked, SHOCKED by how it all went down with the Yankees. Just yesterday I found another tidbit whose irony is off the charts. The chip on its shoulder that Richmond has carried all toward Yankees and the North in general makes absolutely NO SENSE.

    I’ll reveal all in a post coming soon.

  3. MorganLF says:

    I’ve never been. I’m sure monuments boulevard is lovely. Poor Arthur Ashe memorial notwithstanding .

    Robert E. Lee was In His time an honorable man, who I believe was a West Point grad who was offered a senior command by Lincoln in the Union army, despite his beliefs in keeping the union together he followed the secession of his home state Virginia. We know the rest.

    It has always been ironic to me that Arlington cemetery is on his family land. As a Yankee I view him as a traitor, as a lover of history I try to understand the position he took against his country. It’s not one I can easily understand. America is the United States then and now.

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s

%d bloggers like this: